Correctional Services Minister Pieter Groenewald has sparked national debate by suggesting the reintroduction of corporal punishment to help reduce prison overcrowding and tighten crime deterrence. With over 60,000 awaiting-trial detainees and a strained parole system, Groenewald argues it’s time to re-examine how South Africa addresses crime and punishment.
This includes tough parole policies, deportation of foreign offenders, and controversial calls for alternative penalties.
Critics of Minister Groenewald’s comments argue that reintroducing corporal punishment is a regressive and ineffective approach to criminal justice. Many have called the proposal “nonsense,” emphasising that it fails to address the deeper, systemic issues driving crime, such as poverty, broken communities, and inadequate youth support. Opponents warn that corporal punishment perpetuates cycles of violence and has been proven to be an unreliable deterrent. They stress that solutions should focus on rehabilitation, social support, and preventative measures rather than returning to punitive practices banned decades ago for being inhumane and unconstitutional.
Have your say – should South Africa revisit its approach to criminal justice and punishment?
Your voice matters. Take part in shaping our justice system. Participate now and share your view on this critical national debate.
About DearSA – Where Data Meets Democracy
DearSA is South Africa’s leading public participation platform, empowering citizens to have a direct say in government decisions that impact their lives. We bridge the gap between residents and policymakers by ensuring that public input is collected, analyzed, and presented effectively to decision-makers.
DearSA, is where data meets democracy, ensures that public participation directly influences policy decisions. By completing this form, your comments will be sent to Parliament for consideration.
How Can You Help?
Share this campaign link with your neighbours, friends, family, and colleagues so they too can submit their comment to Parliament. Let’s stand together and be heard—a stronger Constitution starts with you!
Contribute to democracy
Please consider supporting our platform and help reach more participants.
A small amount creates a huge impact. DearSA® is a registered South African non-profit organisation and, like all non-profits, does not qualify for relief funding from government. Please assist where you can.
.png)
Share
Participate in this poll
Total participants: -